Why Costco stock is seemingly forever priced for perfection: Morning Brief – Yahoo Finance

This article first appeared in the Morning Brief. Get the Morning Brief sent directly to your inbox every Monday to Friday by 6:30 a.m. ET. Subscribe
Monday, December 5, 2022
Today's newsletter is by Brian Sozzi, editor-at-large and anchor at Yahoo Finance. Follow Sozzi on Twitter @BrianSozzi and on LinkedIn. Read this and more market news on the go with Yahoo Finance App.
Seven years into retirement as a stock analyst, I can confidently say these two things: One, I don’t miss building multi-factor models in Excel; and two, I do sometimes miss covering Costco’s stock.
Costco, hands down, was one of my favorite stocks to provide client coverage on. I always knew what I would be getting from management: clear, concise guidance on earnings calls married with stellar and consistent real-world execution.
If I had questions, I could just go inside a local Costco to grab a $1.50 hot dog combo and analyze, analyze, and analyze some more.
A particularly interesting aspect to covering Costco — Yahoo Finance's "Company of the Year" for 2022 — was the stock’s valuation. For as long as I have been studying Costco’s stock — let’s go with 18 years — it has always traded on valuation multiples that were well above the S&P 500 and peers such as Target and Walmart. In other words, Costco’s stock is perpetually stuck in a land of priced for perfection.
What made that tricky is that Costco could post a blowout monthly sales number and the stock would get whacked “just because” a few analysts wanted MORE of a blowout.
Present day is no exception.
Costco’s stock got slammed by 7% last Thursday and screamed to the top of our Top Trending Tickers page because November sales excluding gas and foreign exchange impacts only rose 5.3%. In October, sales rose 6.7%.
The month to month sales slowdown isn’t going to cut it for a stock trading on a forward P/E multiple of 36 times, according to Yahoo Finance data. On the other hand, the S&P 500 is trading on a forward price-to-earnings multiple of 19 times.
So why is Costco’s stock seemingly forever priced for perfection? A couple things to acknowledge that I think will be useful in your analysis of other companies:
Costco has a recurring revenue stream in the annual amount people pay to be a Costco member. Wall Street will tend to assign a higher P/E ratio to those companies that have recurring revenue streams as it provides a margin of safety — see Apple and any software-as-a-service company. When Costco inevitably raises membership fees in 2023, sit back and watch the stock take off as this high margin revenue stream becomes even more of a profit tailwind.
Costco is viewed as a better, more consistent operator relative to pure rivals such as BJ Wholesale and Sam’s Club. Looked at another way, you want to pay more to own a stock of a company that over time outperforms its peer set fundamentally.
Costco is a cash cow, in large part due to the cash flow from its aforementioned recurring memberships. Costco has historically plowed that excess cash into opening more new clubs to generate more high margin membership fee income. It’s a virtuous cycle.
Having said all of this, it’s reassuring to know that analysts still in the game today continue to wrestle with the great valuation debate on Costco.
“The valuation does give some people some angst because they are at such a big premium to the market," Goldman Sachs retail Kate McShane told me. "They're at such a big premium to Walmart and other big box retailers that some people don't totally understand it or they can't really bridge the gap between them. Sure, we know Costco is a great retailer, but should they be at a 10 turns higher valuation [PE ratio] than Walmart?”
Cheers to no more discounted cash flow analysis. Happy Trading!
More Yahoo Finance Company of the Year 2022 coverage:
Meet Yahoo Finance's Company of the Year: Costco
How we chose Costco to be Yahoo Finance's Company of the Year
Costco stock: 5 takes from Wall Street analysts
Why some of our 'best company' picks didn't stay that way
Economy
9:45 a.m. ET: S&P Global U.S. Services PMI, November final (46.1 expected, 46.1 during prior month)
9:45 a.m. ET: S&P Global U.S. Composite PMI, November final (46.3 during prior month)
10:00 a.m. ET: Factory Orders, October (0.7% expected, 0.3% during prior month)
10:00 a.m. ET: Durable Goods Orders, October final (1.0% during prior month)
10:00 a.m. ET: Durables Excluding Transportation, October final (0.5% expected, 0.5% during prior month)
10:00 a.m. ET: Non-defense Capital Goods Orders Excluding Aircraft, October final (0.7% during prior month)
10:00 a.m. ET: Non-defense Capital Goods Shipments Excluding Aircraft, October final (1.3% during prior month)
10:00 a.m. ET: ISM Services Index, November (53.3 expected, 54.4 during prior month)
Earnings
GitLab (GTLB), Sumo Logic (SUMO)
Click here for the latest stock market news and in-depth analysis, including events that move stocks
Read the latest financial and business news from Yahoo Finance
Download the Yahoo Finance app for Apple or Android
Follow Yahoo Finance on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Flipboard, LinkedIn, and YouTube
Related Quotes
DA Davidson Senior Research Analyst Michael Baker and Cowen Senior Research Analyst Oliver Chen join Yahoo Finance Live to discuss Costco's performance over the past year and why they're bullish on the stock.
Every time a Costco member shops at the warehouse, they're likely to spend $114 on average. And once someone becomes a Costco member, they're likely to stay one for life. It's reported that 90% of…
Warren Buffett is well-known for saying that his preferred holding period for stocks is "forever," and it's not too surprising why. Innovative Industrial Properties (NYSE: IIPR) is a stock I'll never sell because I expect it to keep paying me money for holding it indefinitely. In case you aren't familiar, IIP is a real estate investment trust (REIT) that buys and rents out cultivation floorspace to cannabis companies.
Apple finally unveiled its new AirPods Pro 2 back in October. They don’t represent a huge upgrade by any stretch, but there are some nice … The post AirPods Pro 2 are back down to Black Friday’s $199 price appeared first on BGR.
A soft earnings report and bankruptcy at one of its investees was enough to sink this software favorite.
Energy giant Chevron leads Dow stocks near buy points as the blue chip index leads the current market rally.
Five Wall Street analysts give their hot takes on the prospects for the big-box retailer's stock.
Costco CEO Craig Jelinek speaks with Yahoo Finance about the success of his company in 2022 and his reaction to Costco being named Yahoo Finance's 2022 Company of the Year.
Tesla Inc delivered 100,291 China-made electric vehicles (EVs) in November, the highest monthly sales since its Shanghai factory opened in late 2020, a Xinhua report said on Monday. However, BYD led all brands in China's November EV sales at 229,942 electric cars including plug-in hybrids and pure electric vehicles, three times more than a year earlier and more than double Tesla's tally, China Passenger Car Association data shows. BYD was the top-selling car brand in China in the first four weeks of November, data from China Merchants Bank International shows, outperforming the Volkswagen brand in a reversal that highlights the pressure on legacy brands in the world's largest auto market.
Yahoo Finance unveils its 2022 Company of the Year: Costco.
I don’t care if a candidate for my company’s open position has a criminal record. But I do care about something more important
Costco wins Yahoo Finance's coveted 'Company of the Year' award. Here are the biggest reasons why.
Over the last year, a good number of insiders have significantly increased their holdings in SoFi Technologies, Inc…
It’s easy to get the appeal of restaurant stocks in a normalizing economy. So believes Jim Cramer, the well-known host of CNBC’s Mad Money. Commenting following Fed Chair Jerome Powell’s speech last week, which indicated a willingness by the policy makers to take a less aggressive rate-hiking stance going forward, Cramer has selected several restaurant stocks as looking ripe for the picking. “Maybe the economy’s normalizing here, or at least the Fed chief thinks it could be soon to normalize,” C
Stocks traded lower Monday as investors remained keyed on interest rate policy from the Federal Reserve after a strong U.S. jobs report for November. Rackspace Technology (RXT) sank 9.2% after the multi-cloud software and services company said a security incident affected its Hosted Exchange environment this weekend. Cannabis stocks were on the rise after President Joe Biden signed a law expanding research on medical marijuana on Friday.
The auto manufacturer's goal is to be producing electric vehicles at an annual run rate of two million by the end of 2026.
SHANGHAI (Reuters) -Tesla plans to cut December output of the Model Y at its Shanghai plant by more than 20% from the previous month, two people with knowledge of electric vehicle maker's production plan said on Monday. The planned production cut comes after Tesla reported record sales in China for November. The output reduction was first reported by Bloomberg, which said the move was a reflection of sluggish demand.
Exxon Mobil's compensation committee approved an increase in the annual salary of Chief Executive Officer Darren Woods to $1.88 million from $1.70 million this year, according to a filing. Kathryn Mikells, who became the company's chief financial officer in August last year, will receive a base pay of $1.22 million in 2023. The company also raised the salaries of its senior vice presidents, effective Jan. 1, 2023.
(Bloomberg) — Credit Suisse Group AG shares rose on the prospect that Saudi Arabian Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman will take a stake in the Swiss firm’s planned investment bank spin out. Most Read from Bloomberg‘Huge, Missing and Growing:’ $65 Trillion in Dollar Debt Sparks ConcernStocks Slide as Fed-Hike Jitters Lift Bond Yields: Markets WrapChina’s Covid Pivot Accelerates as Cities Ease Testing RulesAmbitious Plans to Build Indonesia a Brand New Capital City Are Falling ApartOPEC+ Pauses as
Oil prices pared gains on Monday, following U.S. stock markets lower, after U.S. service sector data raised worries that the Federal Reserve could continue its aggressive policy tightening path. West Texas Intermediate crude (WTI) fell 77 cents to $79.21. U.S. services industry activity unexpectedly picked up in November, with employment rebounding, offering more evidence of underlying momentum in the economy as it braces for an anticipated recession next year.

source